Home Insurance Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage: The Choice That’s Hard to Undo
Expert verified

Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage: The Choice That’s Hard to Undo

Written by

Marianne Hayes headshot Marianne Hayes

Edited by

Kelly Zimmerman headshot Kelly Zimmerman

Expert reviewed by

Joanne Giardini-Russell headshot Joanne Giardini-Russell

Updated November 19, 2026 18 min read

Review history

Article history

Published November 17, 2026.

Reviewed and updated November 19, 2026.

Key takeaways

Original Medicare, which includes Medicare Part A and Part B, doesn’t cover everything. Opting for a supplemental policy can help reduce your parent’s out-of-pocket costs. Medigap and Medicare Advantage are two different options, and each one has unique pros and cons. Medigap premiums are typically higher, but may be your parent’s best bet if they have a health condition or want more flexibility in the event they get sick later on. The right choice for them will depend largely on their budget, where they live, and their preferred healthcare providers.

What's the Difference Between Medigap and Medicare Advantage?

Medicare Supplement Insurance, also known as Medigap, and Medicare Advantage, offer two different ways to bridge gaps that aren’t covered by Original Medicare (Medicare Part A and Part B). Medigap is designed to supplement Original Medicare, while Medicare Advantage replaces it with an entirely new plan that typically includes Medicare Part D coverage. 

Here’s a refresher on the different parts of Medicare:

  • Medicare Part A: Hospital insurance, including short-term skilled nursing facility care, hospice care, and some home health care.
  • Medicare Part B: Medical insurance, including preventative doctor visits, outpatient care, and medical supplies
  • Medicare Part C (or Medicare Advantage): Includes Medicare Part A and Part B; often includes Part D and sometimes includes benefits like vision and dental
  • Medicare Part D: Prescription drug coverage

Your parent cannot have Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time. Each plan or policy covers one person. So if your other parent needs health insurance, they’ll also need to get their own coverage. If your parent needs additional coverage to fill in any gaps, they can look toward additional coverage, such as hospital indemnity plans, cancer plans, etc. 

One additional difference to weigh when deciding between a Medigap policy and a Medicare Advantage plan: 

  • A Medigap policy is guaranteed renewable, so the insurer can’t cancel it or change its benefits as long as your parent keeps paying the premium. However, the premium itself can go up over time. 
  • Medicare Advantage plans, on the other hand, can change their costs, benefits, provider networks, and drug coverage from year to year, and your parent’s plan will send an Annual Notice of Change each fall outlining what’s new.

Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage at a Glance

Original Medicare
(Part A + Part B)
MedigapMedicare Advantage
Provider accessYou can visit any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare.You can visit any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare.HMOs may offer preferred pricing; with a PPO you may go out of network, but typically at a higher cost. All plans vary regarding national access to coverage; check plans before enrolling.
Referrals for specialistsTypically not requiredNot requiredTypically required for Medicare Advantage plans that are structured as HMOs
Drug coverageNot included (you’ll need Medicare Part D for prescription drug coverage)Not included (you’ll need Medicare Part D for prescription drug coverage)Plans often include Part D coverage
Out-of-pocket limitsNo annual limitThe majority of policies pay most of any leftover out-of-pocket costs not covered by Original Medicare. Amounts vary by plan.Part A and Part B: In 2026, up to $9,250 for in-network care; up to $13,900 combined. Part D out-of-pocket costs are capped at $2,100.
Dental, vision, hearingNot coveredNot coveredSome coverage is often included, but plans vary.
Travel coverageAccepted anywhere in the United States (not covered out of the country)Accepted anywhere in the United States; some policies cover a portion of emergency care needed outside of the country (up to the policy’s limits).Usually only accepted within a specific service area (except for emergency care or urgent care)
Some plans cover emergencies that happen outside of the U.S.
Premium structurePart A is typically premium-free, but you’ll pay a monthly premium for Part B coverage. A deductible and coinsurance apply.Monthly premium due on top of Part B premium (and Part D if you enroll). Deductible and copays may apply.You’ll pay your Part B premium, plus a Medicare Advantage premium (many plans charge $0). All plans have deductibles, and copays or coinsurance. The plans max out of pocket amount will vary by plan.

Was this comparison helpful?

What Medigap and Medicare Advantage Actually Cost You

Your parent will likely pay more money in upfront premiums for Medigap, but they could spend less in the long term when compared to Medicare Advantage. Their health and future medical costs will play a significant role. No one can predict the future, which is why choosing a supplemental plan isn’t so black and white.

Here’s a quick cost breakdown that can help you support your parent.

Medigap

Costs can vary depending on the level of coverage, the insurer, and where your parent lives. Most policies cover all or part of the Part A deductible ($1,736 in 2026), but they’ll be responsible for their Part B premium. This is typically $202.90 per month in 2026, but may be more depending on their income. Part B also has a $283 deductible.

If your parent opts for a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan, they’ll pay a monthly premium for it, plus their share of the cost for their prescriptions. Many plans also have a deductible. In 2027, the highest deductible a plan can charge is $700 (up from $615 in 2026), and some plans charge less or none at all. After the deductible, they’ll still pay copays or coinsurance on their prescriptions until they reach the yearly out-of-pocket limit of $2,400 in 2027. Once they hit that limit, covered drugs cost nothing for the rest of the year.

All Medigap policies must adhere to federal and state laws. In most states, there are 10 kinds of Medigap policies, and each one offers a different level of coverage. These benefits are standardized by policy type. That means two insurers selling the same plan must offer the same benefits. The main difference will be the price point.

Medicare Advantage

Some Medicare Advantage plans charge a premium, which can vary widely. Others have a $0 premium and may cover some or all of your Part B premium. The average Medicare Advantage premium in 2026 was estimated to be $14 a month. The majority of plans include Medicare Part D drug coverage and some level of dental, vision, and hearing coverage.

Out-of-pocket spending limits apply. In 2026, that’s up to $9,250 for in-network costs (or up to $13,900 in combined in-network and out-of-network costs). That cap will increase to $9,850 in 2027. Part D out-of-pocket costs are capped at $2,100, and will increase to $2,400 in 2027.

Even though Medicare Advantage caps annual spending, the annual limit resets every year. That means your parent could end up paying up to their plan’s limit every year they experience high medical costs, like when managing an ongoing illness. Medigap, on the other hand, typically charges a higher premium but can keep annual cost-sharing very low. This is an important consideration when helping your parents with their long-term healthcare and financial planning.

Medigap and Medicare Advantage Costs Compared*

Original Medicare
(Part A + Part B)
MedigapMedicare Advantage
PremiumPart A: $0 for most people

Part B: $202.90 per month (or more depending on your income)
Costs vary based on the insurer, where you live, and your level of coveragePremiums can vary widely; some have a $0 premium and may cover some or all of your Part B premium
Deductibles in 2026Part A: $1,736 per benefit period

Part B: $283 per year
Many policies cover all or part of your Part A deductible; some Medigap policies also require a person to pay the Part B deductibleVaries based on plan
Coinsurance /copaymentsPart A:
For inpatient hospital stays:
 Days 1-60: $0 after you pay your Part A deductible
Days 61-90: $434 per day 
Days 91 and more: $868 per day for every lifetime reserve day you use (you get 60 during your lifetime)

After your lifetime reserve days are used: You pay all costs
Part B: Typically 20% of the cost of each service or item covered by Medicare (after you’ve paid your deductible)
Some Medigap policies require coinsurance payments that can range from 25% to 50%, depending on the policy. For example, Plan K pays 50% and Plan L pays 75%.Varies based on plan
Annual out-of-pocket ceilingNo limitSome Medigap policies do not have out-of-pocket limits because they cover 100% of coinsurance and copayments for original Medicare.

Other Medigap policies cover less and do have out-of-pocket limits.
In 2026, up to $9,250 for in-network costs (increasing to $9,850 in 2027)

In 2026,up to $13,900 in combined in-network and out-of-network costs. (increasing to $14,800 in 2027)

Part D out-of-pocket costs are capped at $2,100 (increasing to $2,400 in 2027).
Drug costsNot covered (you’ll either need to pay out of pocket or enroll in a Medicare Part D plan)Not covered (you’ll either need to pay out of pocket or enroll in a Medicare Part D plan)Many plans include Medicare Part D coverage
Extra benefitsNoneSome policies cover a portion of certain foreign travel emergencies, up to the policy’s limit. Dental, vision, and hearing not included.Many plans may cover some level of extra benefits

*Some costs may continue to change in 2027

Are the differences clear?

Weekly guidance

Short, useful notes for people caring for a parent

Money, care decisions, and legal planning. One email a week.

Free guide plus weekly guidance. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why Medigap May Be the Better Starting Choice

With Medigap, you can visit any provider that accepts Medicare. You don’t have to stay within a certain network, and in most states, you don’t need prior authorization for services. Most Medigap policies will also cover most of your out-of-pocket costs.

“In my professional opinion and experience, it is potentially a much better option to have Original Medicare with a Medigap policy and drug plan in a lot of cases,” says Melinda Caughill, Medicare expert and co-founder of 65 Incorporated, which provides unbiased Medicare consulting and educational services. 

Caughill says she has worked with people who loved their Medicare Advantage plan while they were healthy and playing pickleball, but hated it when they couldn’t get a prior authorization for cancer treatment. This can add up to a huge expense if your parent becomes ill and can’t wait around to get the care they need.

“The out-of-pocket spending limits only apply when you are following the plan’s rules,” says Caughill. “If you don’t get prior authorization when required, and you go ahead with a service anyway, you pay the whole bill.”

Medigap enrollment timing and eligibility

Medigap has strict enrollment and eligibility requirements in most states. While a pre-existing health condition cannot prevent someone from joining a Medicare Advantage plan, getting Medigap is usually a different story. In most states, an insurer can charge you a higher premium or deny you coverage altogether based on your health if you try to sign up outside of your one-time Medigap open enrollment period.  

More about the Medigap open enrollment period:

  • This is a 6-month window that begins the first month you have Medicare Part B and you’re 65 or older. 
  • You’ll get preferred prices during this period, and insurers cannot charge you more if you have a preexisting condition. 
  • If there is a pre-existing condition and the policyholder lacks prior coverage, there may be a waiting period up to 6 months before Medigap kicks in. 
  • If your parent misses this enrollment window and does not have Medigap guaranteed issue right (a federal protection that allows you to buy a Medigap policy outside your initial open enrollment period without answering health questions), you’ll likely need to meet the insurance company’s underwriting requirements to qualify. However, state rules vary.

A few states have looser eligibility criteria. Connecticut and New York, for example, require that insurers sell Medigap policies throughout the entire year. Insurers in Massachusetts generally do the same.

Renewal: 

Once you have a Medigap policy, these contracts are guaranteed renewable. You pay the bill; you get to keep it. This is a federal rule and applies in every state. You’re entitled to keep your plan for life, regardless of your health, as long as you continue paying your premium.

When Medicare Advantage Is the Right Choice

In some cases, Medicare Advantage might make the most sense for your parent. You may consider it if:

  • The Medigap premium is too high. This is important if your parent is on a fixed budget. Some Medicare Advantage plans have a $0 premium. Medicaid may also pick up out-of-pocket costs like deductibles and coinsurance if they qualify.
  • They want to bundle prescriptions, dental, vision, and hearing into one plan. This simplicity can be a real benefit of having a Medicare Advantage plan, especially since your parent won’t need a separate drug plan.
  • Your parent is healthy and comfortable in the Medicare Advantage network: If they don’t have any major or ongoing health concerns, and they’re happy with their provider network, Medicare Advantage may be the right fit.
  • They live in a large, urban area. Location plays a role, but policyholders who live near large hospital networks, such as Houston or Chicago, for example, can have success with Medicare Advantage plans.

Medicare Advantage trial period

Regardless of where you live, federal law allows anyone enrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time to try a 12-month trial. However, there are some caveats, depending on when your parent enrolls in Medicare Advantage:

  • If they are switching from a Medigap plan to try Medicare Advantage, they must do so during open enrollment. If they don’t like Medicare Advantage, they can switch back to Original Medicare and their prior Medigap plan without a health review as long as it’s within the 12-month trial window. If their prior Medigap plan is no longer sold, they have guarantee issue rights into a new Medigap policy.  
  • If they joined Medicare Advantage upon turning 65, they can drop the plan at any point during the 12-month trial and enroll in Medigap.

Your parent can also leave a Medicare Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare during the following times:

  • The annual open enrollment period, which is October 15 to December 7
  • The Medicare Advantage annual open enrollment period, which is January 1 to March 31 for people who are already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan 
  • A special enrollment period if they qualify, like a move to a new zip code that their current Medicare Advantage plan doesn’t serve

How to Decide Between Medigap and Medicare Advantage

Helping a parent choose between Medigap and Medicare Advantage isn’t always easy. Here are some important factors to consider:

  • Their overall health and whether they have any ongoing medical needs
  • If they’re attached to any providers who don’t accept Medicare Advantage
  • If they travel often or split their time between states (Medigap plans are accepted anywhere in the United States.)
  • Their budget and what they can afford to pay, in both upfront premiums and potential out-of-pocket expenses if they get sick down the road
  • Whether they’re within their 6-month Medigap open enrollment window

Can You Switch From Medicare Advantage to Medigap Later?

Yes, but it can be difficult. If your parent is outside of their 6-month Medigap open enrollment period (when they are over age 65 and their Medicare Part B coverage began over 6 months ago), they’ll need to apply for a Medigap policy and be approved before leaving their current Medicare Advantage plan. They’ll also need to enroll in a separate Medicare Part D drug plan. 

If medical underwriting ends up being a roadblock, they can try:

  • Applying with another Medigap insurance carrier 
  • Looking at other Medicare Advantage plans, such as a Special Needs Plan or other plan built for specific groups of people.

There are three kinds of Special Needs Plans:

  1. Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs) for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid
  2. Chronic Condition Special Needs Plans (C-SNPs) for people with certain long-term conditions like diabetes or heart failure
  3. Institutional Special Needs Plans (I-SNPs) for people who live in a nursing home or need that level of care at home

If you need additional help, check Medicare.gov. You can also check out State Health Insurance Assistance Programs (SHIPs), which are government-funded and volunteer-driven organizations. In some cases, you may need to contact Medicare directly for a parent.

Many folks who start with Medicare Advantage consider a switch to Medigap after a diagnosis, but it may be harder to qualify at that point. That’s certainly worth weighing if your parent: 

  • Has a serious or chronic health condition
  • Wants to be able to see specialists without a referral
  • Splits their time between different states
  • Values predictable costs over a low premium

If a Medigap premium feels too high, you can still switch to Medicare Advantage during an available enrollment period. Just know that switching back to a Medigap plan may be tricky or impossible.

FAQ on Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage

Can you have both Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time?

No. You can have Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) with Medigap or standalone Medicare Advantage. You can’t have both.

Can my parent be denied a Medigap plan because of their health?

Yes. If they apply outside of their original open enrollment window or have guarantee issue rights, an insurer may deny them due to a pre-existing health condition. This can be state dependent. Applicants that reside in Connecticut, New York, and Massachusetts, for example, may not be denied due to a pre-existing condition outside the enrollment window.

Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage plans?

Most Medicare Advantage plans require enrollees to use in-network providers and secure prior authorizations for certain medical treatments, particularly with HMO plans. PPOs cover out-of-network care, but at a higher cost. That can be a hurdle for those who need specialized care.

Can you switch from Medicare Advantage to Medigap after a diagnosis?

Yes, you can apply but there’s no guarantee that your application will be approved. The insurer may charge you a higher rate or deny you altogether if you don’t meet their underwriting requirements. Some states like Connecticut and New York cannot deny you and are guarantee-issue states, year round. 

Does Medigap cover prescription drugs?

No. For that you’ll need a separate Part D drug plan.

What happens if my parent misses the 6-month Medigap enrollment window?

They can still apply for a Medigap policy, but they’ll probably need to satisfy medical underwriting standards. This can lead to higher rates or denial.

Is Medicare Advantage really cheaper than Medigap?

Your parent’s total long-term costs will depend on their plan and health needs. With Medicare Advantage, they may end up paying less at first but more in out-of-pocket costs later on if they get sick. Medigap typically charges higher upfront premiums but covers more if they need care.

Does my parent have to switch plans every year?

No. If they’re happy with their plan, they can certainly remain enrolled. However, they may choose to switch if plan costs increase or their in-network providers change.

Is there a question we did not answer here?

What would have made this more useful? ?

Please share your feedback

Related guidance

See SureHarbor first in Google Adding us as a preferred source means our guidance shows higher when you search these topics. Add as a preferred source

Article sources

SureHarbor contributors verify claims against primary sources: government agencies, regulators, peer-reviewed research, and industry data. We cite the original wherever one exists, and we say plainly when a figure is an estimate. Read our editorial standards.

  1. Medicare.gov What Original Medicare covers
  2. Medicare.gov Learn How Medigap Works
  3. Medicare.gov Compare Original Medicare & Medicare Advantage
  4. Washington State – Office of the Insurance Commissioner Compare Medigap and Medicare Advantage plans
  5. Medicare.gov Choosing a Medigap Policy
  6. Medicare.gov Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs)
  7. Medicare.gov Compare Medigap Plan Benefits
  8. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services – CMS.gov Medicare Advantage Rates & Statistics
  9. Medicare.gov Medicare Supplement Insurance: Getting Started
  10. Medicare.gov How much does Medicare drug coverage cost?
  11. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services – CMS.gov Medicare Advantage and Medicare Prescription Drug Programs Expected to Remain Stable in 2026
  12. Medicare.gov Joining a plan
  13. United States – Code of Federal Regulations 42 CFR 422.110 — Discrimination Against Beneficiaries Prohibited
  14. Medicare.gov Get ready to buy
  15. Mass.gov – Commonwealth of Massachusetts Medicare Supplement Plans Offered in Massachusetts 2026
  16. New York Department of Financial Services Protections for Medicare Beneficiaries Residing in New York
  17. Connecticut – ct.gov Benefits Quick Guide & Supplement
  18. Maine.gov Buy/Switch Outside Open Enrollment
  19. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services – CMS.gov Beneficiaries Dually Eligible for Medicare & Medicaid